Which do you prefer, a standalone broadband package or bundle?

Standalone (just the internet)
Bundle (net, phone, tv etc.)

Which service do you most desire to be bundled with a fixed line broadband connection?

Line Rental (Calls etc.)
Television
Mobile Phone (Service)
Mobile Broadband

More Polls | Past Polls Archive
By: MarkJ - 23 July, 2009 (1:01 AM) - Score: 4184 - Fixed Line Broadband
Network operator Entanet UK has warned that many broadband ISPs could be missing a "competitive opportunity" by adopting a risky "wait and see" approach to IPv6 adoption. The group, which supplies several ISPs and is itself an early adopter of IPv6, said that some providers could perhaps be deemed "technically negligent" and risk "compromising network performance" by delaying.

For those not in the know, an IPv4 address is assigned to your computer each time you go online (e.g. 123.23.56.98). It is a unique online identifier made up of four number groupings and allows you to communicate with other computers around the world; not unlike a phone number for voice calls.

Sadly IPv4 addresses are predicted to run out by 2012, though some research suggests it could happen as early as next year. Meanwhile its replacement, IPv6, is already somewhat aged and has been waiting in the wings for years. IPv6 is not only longer but also more secure by design. They are 128bits long, written in hexadecimal and separated by colons; for example:
2ffe:1800:3525:3:200:f8ff:fe21:67cf
Neil Watson, Entanet’s Technical Support Manager, said:

"In the worst case this would make it impossible for ISPs to accommodate any more subscribers. In reality IPv6 is already available and some ISPs are already utilising it, including Entanet. Whilst several of our competitors may not be implementing IPv6 just yet I find it hard to believe that any would be so negligent that they actually reach this crisis point without taking action."

Watson notes that many ISPs are using the "lack of customer demand for IPv6" as an excuse for putting off the investment required to bring their networks up to date, which is despite most new hardware already supporting the technology. Like it or not though that cost is coming and may hit sooner than some providers expect.

Watson concludes:

"By making IPv6 available, the ISP holds a competitive edge as there are few early adopters within the market. Plus, IPv6 offers additional benefits such as increased security through the use of IPSec. By adopting a ‘wait and see’ approach (which seems even more pointless when the only option to wait for is the inevitable) ISPs are not only missing a competitive opportunity. They are compromising network performance and perhaps even becoming technically negligent.

As an early adopter of IPv6, Entanet calls on other ISPs to explain why they are holding off. Just what is it that they are waiting for? What benefits can be obtained (apart from delaying inevitable investment) by adopting a ‘wait until we reach the crisis point’ strategy?

As an end user customer you will be affected by your provider’s choice of strategy. Ask them what their plans are for IPv6 adoption. Are they already IPv6 compatible and, if not, when are they planning to implement it?"

Most consumers and even some businesses don't appear to understand the term 'broadband', so they're unlikely to suddenly begin demanding IPv6 from ISPs, but then it's not as if they should. Do we have to demand that special bolts be installed on the rail network to keep it running? Of course not, because it's common sense to do it.

Never the less we agree with Entanet's BLOG that IPv6, whether you like the idea or not, is an essential upgrade and any ISP that doesn't at least have a plan for tackling it could be in for trouble. Customers could be forced to share IP addresses with other users and performance problems might ensue, which is just one of several potential problems.

Related News:
29 April, 2009 - ARIN Warns ISPs - IPv4 Internet Addresses to be Depleted by 2010
16 May, 2008 - OECD Warns of Internet Address (IPv4) Shortage
27 May, 2008 - EC Sets IPv6 Adoption Target of 25% by 2010
20 August, 2008 - ISPs will Fail to Meet IPv6 Adoption Targets
25 September, 2008 - Vint Cerf Warning - The Internet is Still Running out of IPs
04 December, 2008 - IPv6 Uptake Increases by 300 Percent
Share: SD, STB, FB, Digg, Blink, Del.icio.us, Reddit, Yahoo, Mixx, Propeller, Diigo
Option: Link | Search

Comments: 6

asa logoBob2002
Posted: 23 July, 2009 - 1:12 PM
Link to comment

Are any "consumer" routers supporting IPv6 at the moment ? Until manufacturers (and ISPs) start listing IPv6 as a selling point it won't really take off. noexpression
asa logoMarkJ
Posted: 23 July, 2009 - 4:55 PM
Link to comment

It's not strictly necessary for the router to support IPv6. They can deliver the full IPv6 experience to users over the existing IPv4 Internet using IPv6 transition tech. IPv6 isn't so much a selling point as something that must happen.
asa logoBob2002
Posted: 23 July, 2009 - 10:37 PM
Link to comment

Are you talking about using tunnel brokers ? Black Cat used to do native with dual stack (IIRC) until they disappeared. Native is surely where the world is heading.

Haven't heard much on the IPv6 topic apart from the Enta trials. baffled
asa logoMarkJ
Posted: 24 July, 2009 - 7:53 AM
Link to comment

If you actually want an IPv6 specific service element, as opposed to just knowing that your ISP is IPv6 ready and so won't start sharing your IPv4's with other users, then yes you do need an IPv6 supporting router. Some routers do include it already, even if it's not always obvious from the spec sheet, but they tend to be the more expensive ones.

For ISPs it’s most important to support IPv6 so that they can keep adding new customers, though any new users would need an IPv6 router. What I meant to say in the comment above was that existing IPv4 users don’t strictly have to get an IPv6 router just to stay connected, the ISPs transition tech can cater for them.

AAISP has a good take on all this:
http://www.aaisp.net/news-ipv6-routers.html
asa logogdsm
Posted: 25 July, 2009 - 12:13 AM
Link to comment

It is not only ISP's who need to support IPv6, but the registars too. I have yet to find a .co.uk registrar which can send my IPv6 nameserver glue change requests onto Nominet. Even though Nominet can quite happily support it.
asa logoSimon Leinen
Posted: 28 July, 2009 - 1:53 PM
Link to comment

As to whether there are consumer broadband routers with IPv6 support, the situation isn't as dire as it used to be. Some of Apple's "Airport" wireless routers support it (notably the "Airport Extreme"). D-Link has at least the DIR-600. AVM's "Fritzbox"en have IPv6-capable firmware available as well, and I'm sure that there are others.

Leave a comment


baffled cheese confused cool frown glee laugh mad mixedup noexpression sad sadder shifty shocked smile smirk timid tongue whatever wink 



Characters left (comments containing swear words may not be saved)

Please MAKE A COPY OF YOUR COMMENT so you can re-post if an error occurs.

Enter this code in the field below.
Security Image





Previous News Stories
2 September, 2010
2:58 PM - UK Business ISP Easynet Global and BSkyB Complete Sale to Private Equity LDC - (0)
2:40 PM - Orange UK Joins 3 and T-Mobile in 3G Mobile Broadband Network Share - (0)
1:02 PM - Virgin Media UK Provides Broadband ISP Speed Clarity to Customers - (2)
7:16 AM - UK Consumer Panel Urges Gov to Get Tough on Misleading Broadband ISP Speeds - (0)
2:00 AM - Virgin Media UK Raises Cable Broadband ISP Install Charge to 40 Pounds - (0)
1:16 AM - UK FTTH Fibre Optic Broadband ISP Fibreband Offers Standalone Services - (3)
1 September, 2010
12:56 PM - UK Advertising Watchdog Given Powers to Tackle Broadband ISP Website Ads - (0)
12:10 PM - Top 9 Fastest UK Broadband ISPs Ranked by Speed for August 2010 - (0)
9:01 AM - UK ISP Aquiss Offers FREE Business 40Mb Fibre Optic FTTC Broadband Installs - (0)
7:28 AM - Rural Norfolk UK Campaigners Criticise BT Claims of National Broadband Success - (3)
31 August, 2010
2:17 PM - Fibrecity Offer FREE 100Mb Fibre Optic Broadband Connections to Dundee UK - (2)
1:55 PM - Huawei Helps BT Deploy its Superfast UK Fibre Optic Broadband Service - (0)
1:16 PM - Broadband ISP Migration Problems Still Impact Half of UK Switchers - (0)
8:26 AM - Gadgetshow UK Launch TV Campaign to Stop Bad Broadband Speed Advertising - (2)
7:08 AM - UPDATE BT Group Celebrates 15 Millionth Broadband ISP Connection in the UK - (0)
28 August, 2010
1:00 AM - YouTube UK Launch FREE Broadband Movie Streaming Service - (0)
27 August, 2010
1:35 PM - More than 19 Million UK Households Now Have Internet Access in 2010 - (2)
8:19 AM - UK Law Firm Ralli Seeks Group Action for Harassment Against ACS Law - (2)
7:23 AM - UK ISP XILO Reveals Preliminary 40Mbps Fibre Optic FTTC Broadband Prices - (3)
1:20 AM - Fibrecity Appoints Former BT CEO to Manage Open UK Broadband Platform - (0)
26 August, 2010
2:12 PM - Ofcom UK Illegal Broadband ISP Copyright File Sharing Code Facing Delays - (4)
8:33 AM - UK ISP Entanet Slams USA Google and Verizon Net Neutrality Partnership - (0)
8:06 AM - ZyXEL and Carrier Wales Deliver Uncontended Broadband to Welsh Businesses - (1)
7:19 AM - T-Mobile UK Slashes Pay Per Day Mobile Broadband Price - (0)
1:44 AM - UK ISP TalkTalk Launches 2010 Digital Heroes Awards - (0)
25 August, 2010
12:35 PM - UK ISP PlusNet CEO Departs and is Replaced by Jamie Ford - (2)
9:38 AM - Virgin Media UK Extends 2 MONTHS FREE Broadband Service Bundles - (0)
9:12 AM - WARNING New Phone SCAM Targeting UK Broadband ISP Customers - (1)
8:34 AM - Europe and USA Broadband ISP Prices Continue to Fall as Speeds Increase - (0)
7:31 AM - BT Consistently Fast Broadband Adverts Banned by UK Advertising Authority - (2)
24 August, 2010
12:41 PM - Channel Five Rejoins UK Open Broadband TV Standard Project Canvas - (0)
9:01 AM - PCCW Backed UK Broadband Group Gives Hope to WiMAX Wireless - (7)
8:48 AM - BSkyB Mulling the Closure of Broadband ISP Sibling UK Online - (0)
7:55 AM - Local South West England Council Defines NGA UK Broadband as 5Mbps - (1)
7:05 AM - ACS Law Referred to Disciplinary Tribunal Over UK ISP File Sharing Threat Letters - (1)

Generated in 0.53345 seconds.
DB queries: 8

Copyright © 1999 to Present - ISPreview.co.uk - All Rights Reserved (Terms, Privacy Policy, Links (.), Live Chat & Website Rules).