By: MarkJ - 23 September, 2009 (6:53 AM)
Telecoms giant BT has warned that the high costs involved with tackling illegal UK file sharing (P2P) could result in customers having to pay an extra £2 per month (£24 per year) on their broadband bills. The ISP fears that "wafer thin" profit margins within the industry will cause providers to push any extra costs on to users.

BT added that the current proposals would equate to about £1m per day in added costs, which would be more expensive than the music industry’s loses to piracy in the first place (estimated at £200m per year). The operator then went on to question the fallibility of the methods employed to detect piracy and the industry’s statistical claims (7m illegal UK downloaders), which were recently rubbished by the BBC (here).

John Petter, BT's consumer division boss, told The Mirror:

"[THE CREATIVE INDUSTRY] have lobbied hard and very effectively but that doesn’t make them right. Their claims are melodramatic and assume people would buy all the music that is illegally downloaded, which is nonsense. Laws already exist to enable music companies and other copyright holders to prosecute offenders but they don’t want to take the hit to their public image."

BT continued on to warn that the huge investment required to tackle piracy would quickly be outdone by pirates developing better ways of hiding their activity. Indeed such methods already exist and some would argue that the battle may have already been lost long before it has even begun.

BT's concerns follow moves by the governments Business Secretary, Peter Mandelson, to forcibly add a new "disconnection for suspected pirates" measure into the original Digital Britain report (here). The new proposal caused shock and surprise among many ISPs and consumer groups because it had previously been ruled out.

Law firms currently track suspected illegal P2P activity by monitoring IP addresses, which is highly unreliable. These addresses are assigned to every computer when you go online, yet IP's can easily be spoofed, redirected, shared (internet cafe, businesses etc.) or even hijacked (open Wi-Fi networks). The download itself could also be encrypted, making it nearly impossible for the ISP to verify.

The only true way to tell if somebody has done something illegal is to analyse their computers hard disk drive, otherwise you could just as easily end up targeting innocent users, which has already happened on a number of occasions. Suspending connections based on unreliable data and without a fair trial seems like a gross abuse. ISPs are not a police force and do not own content on the Internet.
Share: Slash., Stumble, Facebook, Digg, Blink, Reddit, Delicious, Diigo
Option: Link | Search

Comments: 5

asa logoLee
Posted: 23 September, 2009 - 4:54 PM
Link to comment

The only true way to tell if somebody has done something illegal is to analyse their computers hard disk drive


Err... except that this too would be presuming guilt and harassing citizens for (illegitimate and arguably illegal) corporate motives.
asa logoMarkJ
Posted: 23 September, 2009 - 5:01 PM
Link to comment

It would form part of the defense for due legal process in a court case, though obviously using it against casual downloaders would be totally OTT.
asa logoMark
Posted: 23 September, 2009 - 10:00 PM
Link to comment

Muddleson's problem is that he has less understanding of the technical and ethical problems involved in what he is proposing than a squeaky rubber duck, but he hasn't let that stop him. It probably sounded like a great idea when he got drunk with his mate David Geffen last month and they spent hours talking a load of b*ll*cks about things they know nothing about.
asa logoxalixioxitac
Posted: 25 September, 2009 - 9:02 AM
Link to comment

Mankind encounter alopecia because of man's hormone dihydrotestosterone excess. The hormone collection tightens a hair follicle and hair dies off and stops growing.
asa logoStricklandRoxie
Posted: 2 April, 2011 - 5:27 PM
Link to comment

All people deserve wealthy life and <a href="http://bestfinance-blog.com/topics/mortgage-loans">mortgage loans</a> or credit loan can make it better. Just because people's freedom is grounded on money state.



Generated in 0.20322 seconds.
DB queries: 8

Copyright © 1999 to Present - ISPreview.co.uk - All Rights Reserved (Terms, Privacy Policy, Links (.), Live Chat & Website Rules).