Which do you prefer, a standalone broadband package or bundle?

Standalone (just the internet)
Bundle (net, phone, tv etc.)

Which service do you most desire to be bundled with a fixed line broadband connection?

Line Rental (Calls etc.)
Television
Mobile Phone (Service)
Mobile Broadband

More Polls | Past Polls Archive
By: MarkJ - 18 May, 2010 (1:01 PM) - Score: 2883 - Fixed Line Broadband
2012 uk 2mbps signThe governments Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) has confirmed rumours that it will appoint a new minister for broadband by the end of this week. The BBC reports that Culture Minister Ed Vaizey is rumoured to be one possible candidate for the role.

Whomever takes the post will immediately find themselves tackling a very difficult set of issues. Firstly they will need to ensure that everybody in the country can receive a minimum broadband download speed of 2Mbps by 2012 (Universal Service Commitment). The USC has cross-party support, though some ISPs feel it does not go nearly far enough.

The General Manager of ISP Entanet UK, Elsa Chen, commented today:

"Since its conception, several parties including Entanet have continually argued that 2Mbps is not enough, especially as the MPs are supposedly striving to make Britain a world leader in the provision of broadband services. Who are they trying to kid…that’ll never happen with a USC of only 2Mbps.

As we have stated in the past, whilst we applaud the government for addressing the digital divide issue, imposing a USC of just 2Mbps will not solve the problem. Instead we will simply be forced to play a continuous game of catch up.

Whilst new bandwidth hungry services and applications continue to increase in popularity (e.g. SaaS, IPTV etc) the faster, more robust connectivity services that are demanded to support these services will continue to be rolled out to the most densely populated areas first.

The UK’s ‘not-spots’ will be left continuously trying to keep up. When they eventually receive their 2Mbps connection by 2012 the rest of the UK will have already been upgraded to ADSL2+ at least, providing speeds of up to 24Mbps. To make a real difference and truly position the UK as a ‘World leader’ in the provision of Internet services, the USC should be set much higher, encouraging further network expansion and innovation."

The new minister will also find themselves being tasked with trying to figure out the best way to support next generation fibre optic broadband deployments. The Conservative/LibDem government has yet to outline any finalised plans, which were not mentioned as part of their post-election coalition deal.

Malcolm Corbett, CEO of the Community Broadband Network (CBN)/INCA, told the BBC :

"We need to appoint a minister as quicky as possible. Without it UK broadband risks drifting and that is not a good thing for UK competitiveness ... Ed Vaizey would be a good bet as he is on top of the issues."

The CBN claims it "supports, promotes and develops community-owned broadband schemes", though FibreStreams Guy Jarvis promptly resigned from its board in January 2009 when, after three years of voluntary and unpaid effort, "it became apparent that certain colleagues on the board had no intention for CBN to ever get back on track and instead wanted to repurpose CBN into a directors consultancy for commercial gain" (here).

Getting back on track. We strongly suspect that the new government will follow the Conservative party approach, not least because Labour and the LibDem's 50p phone line tax proposal has become widely disliked. Instead they would use part of the BBC's TV Licence fee (£130m per year - 3.5% Digital Switchover budget) to help fund a 100Mbps next generation broadband rollout "across most of the population" by 2017. What exactly does "most" mean? 51%? 70%? 99%?

However the Licence fee money would only be used after 2012, allowing the private sector time to tackle the problem itself. To help facilitate this the Conservatives have promised market charges. They want BT and other infrastructure providers to open access into their cable ducts and plan a review of the controversial Fibre Tax.

Suffice to say that the new government has a lot to prove and it would certainly be a promising sign if they got to work on the issues sooner rather than later. Nobody expects a grand rush to happen, not given the current importance of deficit reduction, but putting broadband on the back burner would only make things worse in the long run. Appointing a minister for broadband could help to alleviate some of the concerns.
Share: SD, STB, FB, Digg, Blink, Del.icio.us, Reddit, Yahoo, Mixx, Propeller, Diigo
Option: Link | Search

Comments: 3

asa logoBob2002
Posted: 18 May, 2010 - 3:27 PM
Link to comment

£130m per year is an absolute pittance considering that the Internet has to be the greatest comms invention since the telegraph. Australia have a £20 billion program to deliver 100Mb/s FTTH for 90% of the population. baffled
asa logoMarkJ
Posted: 18 May, 2010 - 4:08 PM
Link to comment

Perhaps but then where else do you get the money from at a time when the country has "no money left", to quote a now ex-government treasury man. Any tax rises have to go towards the deficit, so that's not an option.
asa logoBob2002
Posted: 18 May, 2010 - 4:30 PM
Link to comment

I'm not necessarily suggesting something on the scale of the Australian model but, in the scheme of government spending, £130m is absolute peanuts - even given our current finances. It's less than two Eurofighters or a small percentage of the ridiculous £30 billion high speed rail proposal. baffled

Leave a comment


baffled cheese confused cool frown glee laugh mad mixedup noexpression sad sadder shifty shocked smile smirk timid tongue whatever wink 



Characters left (comments containing swear words may not be saved)

Please MAKE A COPY OF YOUR COMMENT so you can re-post if an error occurs.

Enter this code in the field below.
Security Image





Previous News Stories
2 September, 2010
2:58 PM - UK Business ISP Easynet Global and BSkyB Complete Sale to Private Equity LDC - (0)
2:40 PM - Orange UK Joins 3 and T-Mobile in 3G Mobile Broadband Network Share - (0)
1:02 PM - Virgin Media UK Provides Broadband ISP Speed Clarity to Customers - (2)
7:16 AM - UK Consumer Panel Urges Gov to Get Tough on Misleading Broadband ISP Speeds - (0)
2:00 AM - Virgin Media UK Raises Cable Broadband ISP Install Charge to 40 Pounds - (0)
1:16 AM - UK FTTH Fibre Optic Broadband ISP Fibreband Offers Standalone Services - (3)
1 September, 2010
12:56 PM - UK Advertising Watchdog Given Powers to Tackle Broadband ISP Website Ads - (0)
12:10 PM - Top 9 Fastest UK Broadband ISPs Ranked by Speed for August 2010 - (0)
9:01 AM - UK ISP Aquiss Offers FREE Business 40Mb Fibre Optic FTTC Broadband Installs - (0)
7:28 AM - Rural Norfolk UK Campaigners Criticise BT Claims of National Broadband Success - (3)
31 August, 2010
2:17 PM - Fibrecity Offer FREE 100Mb Fibre Optic Broadband Connections to Dundee UK - (2)
1:55 PM - Huawei Helps BT Deploy its Superfast UK Fibre Optic Broadband Service - (0)
1:16 PM - Broadband ISP Migration Problems Still Impact Half of UK Switchers - (0)
8:26 AM - Gadgetshow UK Launch TV Campaign to Stop Bad Broadband Speed Advertising - (2)
7:08 AM - UPDATE BT Group Celebrates 15 Millionth Broadband ISP Connection in the UK - (0)
28 August, 2010
1:00 AM - YouTube UK Launch FREE Broadband Movie Streaming Service - (0)
27 August, 2010
1:35 PM - More than 19 Million UK Households Now Have Internet Access in 2010 - (2)
8:19 AM - UK Law Firm Ralli Seeks Group Action for Harassment Against ACS Law - (2)
7:23 AM - UK ISP XILO Reveals Preliminary 40Mbps Fibre Optic FTTC Broadband Prices - (3)
1:20 AM - Fibrecity Appoints Former BT CEO to Manage Open UK Broadband Platform - (0)
26 August, 2010
2:12 PM - Ofcom UK Illegal Broadband ISP Copyright File Sharing Code Facing Delays - (4)
8:33 AM - UK ISP Entanet Slams USA Google and Verizon Net Neutrality Partnership - (0)
8:06 AM - ZyXEL and Carrier Wales Deliver Uncontended Broadband to Welsh Businesses - (1)
7:19 AM - T-Mobile UK Slashes Pay Per Day Mobile Broadband Price - (0)
1:44 AM - UK ISP TalkTalk Launches 2010 Digital Heroes Awards - (0)
25 August, 2010
12:35 PM - UK ISP PlusNet CEO Departs and is Replaced by Jamie Ford - (2)
9:38 AM - Virgin Media UK Extends 2 MONTHS FREE Broadband Service Bundles - (0)
9:12 AM - WARNING New Phone SCAM Targeting UK Broadband ISP Customers - (1)
8:34 AM - Europe and USA Broadband ISP Prices Continue to Fall as Speeds Increase - (0)
7:31 AM - BT Consistently Fast Broadband Adverts Banned by UK Advertising Authority - (2)
24 August, 2010
12:41 PM - Channel Five Rejoins UK Open Broadband TV Standard Project Canvas - (0)
9:01 AM - PCCW Backed UK Broadband Group Gives Hope to WiMAX Wireless - (7)
8:48 AM - BSkyB Mulling the Closure of Broadband ISP Sibling UK Online - (0)
7:55 AM - Local South West England Council Defines NGA UK Broadband as 5Mbps - (1)
7:05 AM - ACS Law Referred to Disciplinary Tribunal Over UK ISP File Sharing Threat Letters - (1)

Generated in 0.52726 seconds.
DB queries: 8

Copyright © 1999 to Present - ISPreview.co.uk - All Rights Reserved (Terms, Privacy Policy, Links (.), Live Chat & Website Rules).