
Consumer magazine Which? has today published the results from a new survey of 5,014 adult consumers who, over the past year (2026), either haggled or switched providers. The results claim that those who switched both their broadband and TV package alongside their mobile contract could make the biggest average combined savings of up to £429 a year.
For example, Mobile customers who switched from a contract including a handset to a SIM-only deal once their phone was paid off made the biggest individual savings, taking an average of £258 a year off their bills. Consumers who switched a broadband and TV package similarly saved £171 a year, while those who only switched broadband saved £106 and those who only switched mobile saved £93.
Consumers who switched away from the largest providers also saw some of the most significant savings. For example, those who left EE saved an average of £161 a year, while those who left O2 saved £142. However, not everybody may want to change provider (e.g. you could be happy with the service), and in those cases it can sometimes be worth trying to haggle for a better deal.
Advertisement
For example, when haggling, broadband customers saved an average of £50 per year, while those who switched a bundled broadband and TV package saved £82 and mobile customers saw savings of £42. In terms of specific providers, Virgin Media and BT broadband customers saved an average of £60 and £59 respectively by haggling, while Sky Broadband and Virgin broadband and TV customers saved £96 and EE and iD Mobile customers saved £70 and £69 respectively.
Table of average savings made by switching away from provider
| Broadband provider | Annual saving | TV & broadband provider | Annual saving | Mobile provider | Annual saving |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BT | £162 | Sky Broadband and TV | £265 | EE | £161 |
| Virgin Media | £149 | Virgin Media | £188 | O2 | £142 |
| EE | £126 | BT | £141 | Vodafone | £114 |
| Sky Broadband | £103 | EE | £92 | Three UK | £80 |
| Vodafone | £80 | TalkTalk | £37 | Sky Mobile | £80 |
| TalkTalk | £40 | Tesco | £47 | ||
| Plusnet | £33 | BTMobile | £42 | ||
| Giffgaff | £17 | ||||
| Lebara | £2 |
Table of average savings made by haggling with provider
| Broadband provider | Annual saving | TV & broadband provider | Annual saving | Mobile provider | Annual saving |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Virgin Media | £60 | Sky Broadband and TV | £96 | EE | £70 |
| BT | £59 | Virgin Media | £96 | iD Mobile | £69 |
| Sky Broadband | £56 | BT | £60 | Three UK | £47 |
| Vodafone | £51 | TalkTalk | £59 | Sky Mobile | £44 |
| EE | £44 | EE | £39 | O2 Mobile | £40 |
| TalkTalk | £37 | Vodafone | £13 | Vodafone | £40 |
| Plusnet | £21 | Tesco Mobile | £19 | ||
| Lebara | £4 | ||||
| Giffgaff | -£4 | ||||
| BTMobile | -£6 |
However, it’s important to say that haggling is more likely to work with providers, particularly the biggest players (who have dedicated retentions teams), where discounting is a routine practice. By comparison, smaller providers don’t traditionally offer big discounts to new customers and their prices may be more stable, thus haggling is less likely to return a positive result. But it’s always worth a try, and remember – the worst thing they can say is “no”.
Advertisement
The catch, according to Which?, is that (13%) of mobile customers did nothing when their contract ended (i.e. no attempt to haggle or switch), which compares with only 5% of broadband customers and just 2% of those with broadband and TV packages. Mind you this could reflect customers on providers where they may feel no need to haggle / switch or know it might not deliver them the outcome they want.
Despite this, the study claims that more than half of customers who successfully negotiated a better deal did reduce their bills, including 56% of broadband customers, 59% of broadband and TV customers and 54% of mobile customers. Haggling could also deliver other benefits beyond lower bills – 51% of broadband users who negotiated a better deal were offered an upgraded package, while 42% were offered the same package at a lower price.
The survey suggests that the perceived administrative hassles involved may put some customers off switching or haggling. Which? points out that the vast majority of standalone broadband and mobile customers (84%) and broadband and TV customers (77%) who switched when their contract ended said they found switching easy.
Indeed, it’s now easier for consumers to switch providers than even before, thanks to systems like One Touch Switching (OTS) on broadband and Text-to-Switch (Auto-Switch) on mobile from Ofcom. One other thing to keep in mind is that a lot of providers have now automated the end-of-contract offers process, which will often give you a selection of deals and upgrades to choose from, meaning it’s sometimes possible to keep saving without needing to pick-up the phone (although these online deals aren’t always examples of the best available ones).
Advertisement
UPDATE 11:02am
A spokesperson for the ISPA UK said:
“Now is an excellent time to be a broadband customer, with many options available for consumers to access the best deals, and easy ways for them to check they are getting the best deal. Over 90% of UK premises can now access gigabit connectivity, speeds are rising, real-terms prices are falling, and, as Which? highlights, One Touch Switch has made it easier than ever to move to a better deal in a highly competitive market that gives consumers genuine choice. This is reflected in Ofcom’s data, which shows complaints at a record low.”
Advertisement
No, switching is not always an option in an FTTP world where there’s so much concern about overbuild, especially in the era of mid price contract rises and 2-year contracts. They should be banned for single FTTP providers. I’m currently trapped with only CommunityFibre (who are utter trash) providing FTTP.
As usual, Ofcom’s fault.
Looking at the current options on the Community Fibre offer page, they offer a 12 month contract option which is an Ofcom requirement of all ISP’s. This 12 month offer still comes with free installation and a free router with the only increase at the end of the term. Plus they show as offering a 30 day cancellation guarantee.
Blaming Ofcom for your own purchasing decisions seems harsh.
My guess is you will still have Openreach SoGEA available as it covers almost all non Openreach FTTP locations so if Community Fibre is as poor as you report, you do have a switching option to what should be a reliable option that is sill used by millions, albeit with lower headline speeds than CF FTTP.
https://communityfibre.co.uk/deals#residential-packages
I do not know why you are moaning
about Community Fibre as they are better
than BT, they have Symmetric Speeds
The same Speed up and down
and up to 5 gig Broadband
and a new TV service if you wish