
The UK telecoms, media and internet content regulator, Ofcom, has closed their enforcement programme for the newest consumer broadband and phone switching system (One Touch Switching). The regulator found that, despite some initial problems, the majority of customers are now successfully switching providers using OTS.
The OTS system, which went live on 12th September 2024 via a central messaging platform that is run by the industry-funded One Touch Switching Company (TOTSCo), is a Gaining Provider Led (GPL) process where the customer contacts their new (“gaining“) ISP to start and manage the process on their behalf.
However, regular readers may recall that this system had a bit of a bumpy start, due in part to TOTSCo’s platform initially being in somewhat of a beta state and a number of ISPs failing to fully support the platform at launch. Nevertheless, various improvements have been made since then, and the system is already helping around 1.8 million consumers to switch ISP every year (it’s also in the process of being extended to business connections).
Advertisement
Despite the improvements, OTS does still sometimes suffer from problems, such as with matching customer details between providers and the fact that a very small number of providers are still not always adhering to the OTS process. But TOTSCo are working on improvements (here) and Ofcom now seems generally pleased enough with its performance.
Ofcom Statement on OTS Enforcement
On 3 April 2023, Ofcom introduced new rules regarding the process for residential customers to switch their broadband and/or landline services. This new process, One Touch Switch (OTS), is a requirement under Conditions C7.18 – C7.27 of Ofcom’s General Conditions.
Under OTS, a customer’s new provider must organise the switch. This removes the need for customers to speak with their current provider to cancel their contract before switching, which can put customers off changing providers. As such, OTS provides a simpler and quicker switching process, allowing customers to shop around with ease to find the best price and services for their needs.
Despite extensive engagement prior to the implementation deadline, industry failed to implement OTS by 3 April 2023. As a result, Ofcom opened an industry-wide enforcement programme on the same day. The objectives for the programme were to ensure that OTS was delivered to a high standard as quickly as possible, and that it works effectively and reliably for customers in accordance with agreed specifications.
OTS was successfully launched for most customers on 12 September 2024. From the point of launch, Ofcom monitored the progress that providers were taking to increase the number of customers who were able to benefit from OTS. Through this, we became aware of issues affecting the matching rates between different providers. In January 2025 we issued a formal information request to understand the issue and its impact on consumers.
Based on this evidence we concluded that, across industry as a whole, the majority of customers are successfully switching providers using OTS. Our analysis did, however, show that some providers were using an alternative switching method (i.e. something other than OTS) when repeated match attempts via OTS had failed. We engaged with relevant providers on this point and are now satisfied that usage of this alternative switching method has stopped.
Accordingly, Ofcom is now closing this enforcement programme. Ofcom will continue to closely monitor industry-wide compliance with our OTS rules. Should we identify evidence that communication providers are failing to participate adequately in OTS, we will not hesitate to take enforcement action.
Advertisement
Until this is done for all Openreach products (eg EAD leased lines, DFA and others eg wavelength) the real “bonus” of OTS is moot on business. There’s literally zero reason a leased line shouldn’t be able to be switched easily whe out of contract compared to a broadband line.
Leased lines etc *are* in scope already – if sold to residential premises.
Ofcom: the regulator that doesn’t seem to want to regulate.
It has now closed its enforcement programmes on both 999 calling access and broadband switching. In the case of One Touch Switch, providers missed Ofcom’s own deadline by around 17 months before the regulator finally declared success.
A regulator’s job isn’t simply to open investigations, request updates, and then close the file. It’s to enforce the rules it creates. When deadlines are missed, consumers suffer, and enforcement never seems to arrive, the message to industry is clear: compliance is optional.
At times, Ofcom looks less like a regulator and more like an observer with a clipboard.
I’ve been with Uno Broadband for over 15 years and finally switched away. My new provider said that OTS didn’t work as Uno didn’t appear on the database. No idea who was at fault here but I had no issues manually cancelling my existing service with Uno. It was no big deal.
A regulator that can pass rules but not actually enforced them is essentially useless
OTS is great in theory but when the burden to set it up is the same for small WISP as it is for a multinational then the small guys are once again at a disadvantage
Not only that but large providers are still either completely missing from the scheme, most notably Starlink, or often return “no match found” despite the service being a perfect match
Lets not rain of Ofcoms spin parade, or wait until all teh results are in (did someone say quit while ahead / not caught), and how is the business switching been completed yet.
Do we think that with a lack of enforcement ( although not liek anything was actively policed) the weasels wont start comming out to play..? No cat’let of course the mice won’t come out to play….
I’m trying to move from 1p Broadband to *ANY* new provider and the One Touch Switch does not work. It can’t match my details. I’ve tried several potential new ISPs and they all fail. I’m told to contact my new prospective ISP but this would mean and incentive deal others receive would not be applicable.I’m in an area which doesn’t have FTTC yet, it has “been coming next year” for a long time. Stuck on FTTC, Openreach punishes the ISP by inflating prices. Who could make up this mess? I regularly advise friends of the best offer in their location but for once, I’m unable to do it myself. 38 years in the IT industry. Sham on Ofcom and Totsco.