
The UK Government has today confirmed a dramatic U-turn, which means that new core and non-core 5G kit from Chinese tech giant Huawei will be banned from use in mobile networks from 31st December 2020. But existing kit will get until 2027 for removal and a decision on FTTP broadband ISPs will come later.
The move represents a significant shift from the UK’s adopted position in January 2020 (here), which only banned operators from installing Huawei’s kit in the sensitive core part of their networks, but allowed its continued use in non-core parts (e.g. 5G antennas, FTTC cabinets, FTTP ONTs in homes etc.). A cap of 35% was also placed on the company’s kit to ensure that operators made use of other suppliers (BT alone forecast a £500m hit from this).
Part of the reason for January’s decision was because completely banning Huawei could have made the roll-out of new 5G mobile, and also some fixed broadband ISP networks, both much slower and more expensive to achieve. Such a ban would have thus impacted PM Boris Johnson’s recent £5bn pledge to ensure that every UK home can access gigabit (1Gbps) speed broadband networks by the end of 2025.
Advertisement
Since then several further events have conspired to damage the perception of China within the UK, not least their questionable response to the early outbreak of COVID-19 (Coronavirus) and the country’s new security law for Hong Kong. The imposition of even stricter sanctions against Huawei by the USA (i.e. perhaps forcing it to rely on less trustworthy components) is another big issue.
Meanwhile the looming trade deal between the UK and USA (as well as between the USA and China) is also a consideration. In short, whatever the realities or falsehoods of the original security concerns directed toward Huawei (major security vulnerabilities can crop up anywhere, just ask Cisco etc.), wider politics and pressures may now be starting to weigh on the Government and hence today’s significant change of strategy.
At this point it’s worth remembering that the original decision in January followed a 2019 report from the oversight board of the Huawei Cyber Security Evaluation Centre (HCSEC), which warned that “further significant technical issues” had been identified in Huawei’s engineering processes, leading to “new risks in the UK telecommunications networks” (full summary). At the same time it also said that “no material progress has been made by Huawei in the remediation of the issues.”
The board said it could “only provide limited assurance” that all risks to national security from Huawei’s involvement in the UK’s critical networks could be sufficiently mitigated long-term. Naturally Huawei has always denied accusations that they are a security threat and in a public letter said, “Huawei has never and will never use UK-based hardware, software, or information gathered in the UK or anywhere else globally, to assist other countries in gathering intelligence. We would not do this in any country.”
Advertisement
However, critics of the company often point toward China’s new National Intelligence Law, which was passed in 2017 and demands that organisations “support, co-operate with and collaborate in national intelligence work.” The absence of true democracy in China might thus, they argue, make it very difficult for any company to refuse such a request.
Google’s former CEO, Eric Schmidt, has also claimed “there’s no question that information from Huawei routers has ultimately ended up in hands that would appear to be the state … However that happened, we’re sure it happened.” Schmidt, who now chairs the Pentagon’s Defence Innovation Board, says it’s better to think of the company as doing “signals intelligence” work, much like a spy agency.
Meanwhile Donald Trump has taken a strict line and effectively banned companies around the world from working with Huawei, with some limited exceptions. The move has stunted the firm’s Smartphone and other consumer products, such as by removing access to Google’s popular Apps, although that aspect is less relevant to their mobile and broadband infrastructure business.
Sadly, we can’t examine the substance of the security fears that surround Huawei because such issues are a matter for national security and intelligence agencies (i.e. they’re secret), which is impossible for ordinary folk to judge. We wouldn’t be so bold as to assume we know better. However, it seems unlikely that so many countries would be creating such a fuss if there wasn’t a serious concern, which has been going on since long before Donald Trump came to power.
Advertisement
A few weeks ago there was talk of imposing a total ban by 2023, except a significant amount of Huawei’s kit currently exists across various fixed broadband and mobile networks (including inside homes, on masts and in street cabinets etc.). Ripping all of that out in such a short space of time would have been both practically and economically unworkable, particularly given the COVID-19 situation.
Last week BT and Vodafone warned that they would need at least 5-7 years to wean themselves off Huawei (here) and the costs involved could be in the high hundreds of millions or even single digital billions of pounds per operator. But those comments were largely made in reference to 4G and 5G mobile networks, which didn’t consider fixed line broadband.
Since then BT’s CEO, Philip Jansen, has further suggested that it would be “impossible” to totally remove Huawei’s kit from everywhere in under 10 years. Failure to factor for this could thus result in service “blackouts,” warned both operators. Lest we forget the need to continue support for existing Huawei kit until such time as it can be removed or replaced (operators are thus stockpiling kit to cover network faults etc.).
Suffice to say that the Government’s final strategy has sought to strike a degree of balance between the demands for a BAN and what is actually workable. The idea being to prevent new deployments, while allowing support to continue for existing kit until a more natural (end-of-life) progression can be adopted for the removal or replacement work.
Today’s Key Decisions
* From 31st December 2020 telecommunications providers must not buy any 5G equipment from “high risk vendors” like Huawei or ZTE (legal requirement).
* Removal of existing 5G equipment must take place by the end of 2027.
* Existing ban on Huawei from most sensitive “core” parts of 5G network remains in place during this period.
* A different approach is to be taken for “full fibre” (FTTP) and older fixed broadband networks. The Government are advising FTTP operators to “transition away from purchasing new Huawei equipment” and a technical consultation will be launched to determine the transition timetable, “but we expect this period to last no longer than two years.”
The above requirements will be set out in law by the Telecoms Security Bill (due to be introduced into parliament this autumn 2020). However the UK Digital Secretary, Oliver Dowden, noted that the earlier January 2020 decision (partial ban) “had already set back [the 5G] rollout by a year and cost up to a billion pounds,” before adding that the new change would add another year to that delay (2 years) and “will add up to half a billion to the costs.” But it gets worse.
“Requiring operators, in addition, to remove Huawei equipment from their 5G networks by 2027 will add hundreds of millions to the cost and further delay roll out. This means a cumulative delay to 5G rollout of two to three years and costs of up to two billion pounds,” added Dowden. In other words, the quicker the removal, the bigger the cost and delay.
Naturally providers that don’t make much (or any) use of telecoms kit from the Chinese firm, such as O2, will have a better time of things. Meanwhile those that do harness a lot of kit from Huawei, such as BT (EE and Openreach) and Vodafone, are likely to face a much bigger challenge in adapting to the Government’s new strategy.
Nevertheless, mobile and broadband providers now face the stark reality of a significant shift in the national relationship with one of the market’s key suppliers, which is not only going to be extremely costly to tackle but will inevitably cause some delay and disruption.
Crucially though they seem to have left the decision on fixed broadband and related Fibre-to-the-Premises (FTTP) networks until a later date, pending the outcome of another technical consultation.
Oliver Dowden MP, UK Digital Secretary, said:
“5G will be transformative for our country, but only if we have confidence in the security and resilience of the infrastructure it is built upon.
Following US sanctions against Huawei and updated technical advice from our cyber experts, the government has decided it is necessary to ban Huawei from our 5G networks.
No new kit is to be added from January 2021, and UK 5G networks will be Huawei free by the end of 2027. This decisive move provides the industry with the clarity and certainty it needs to get on with delivering 5G across the UK.
By the time of the next election we will have implemented in law an irreversible path for the complete removal of Huawei equipment from our 5G networks.”
The big question now will be whether or not the Government’s harder stance will be enough to placate the 60 or so rebels MPs who have advocated for a ban that can be implemented sooner. The MPs had recently adjusted their position and sought to prevent the purchase of new kit in the next 12 months, while allowing until 2025 or 2026 for it to be completely eliminated.
At the time of writing we haven’t yet had a chance to read the latest report from the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC), which has provided much of the fuel for today’s announcement. However, as above, we already have a reasonable idea of the line it will tow.
One final point to make is that the Government have pledged to bring new scale vendors into the UK market by “removing barriers to entry, providing commercial incentives and creating large scale opportunities for new vendors to enter the UK market.” No details of this were provided.
UPDATE 1:32pom
Few will be surprised to see that one of the first reactions has come from Huawei’s arch rival, Ericsson.
Arun Bansal, Ericsson’s President of Europe and Latin America, said:
“Today’s decision removes the uncertainty that was slowing down investment decisions around the deployment of 5G in the UK. It is now time for the industry to come together and start delivering on the promise of creating a world-leading 5G network for the people, businesses and economy of the UK.
Ericsson has the technology, experience and supply chain capacity to help accomplish this, and we stand ready to work with the UK operators to meet their timetable, with no disruption to customers.”
UPDATE 2:33pm
Now it’s the turn of the UK Internet Service Providers’ Association (ISPA).
Andrew Glover, ISPA Chair, said:
“The Government’s 5G announcement today provides some welcome clarity to our members who are rolling out networks and providing broadband to consumers and businesses across the UK. We look forward to further consultation with Government to determine the policy for fixed networks with a clear focus on ensuring that our members can roll out new gigabit-capable networks at pace.
As the Secretary of State emphasised today, supply chain interventions have a direct impact on the speed at which networks can be rolled out, so any new restrictions need to be counter-balanced with an appropriate level of support for the sector.
The Government has rightly made upgrading our digital communications infrastructure a priority, we now need to see a clear, ambitious plan from policymakers to help the companies that are leading this charge.”
UPDATE 15th July 2020
BT has estimated that the cost impact from today’s decision “can be absorbed within BT’s initial estimated implementation cost of £500m, as announced by BT on 30th January 2020 in order to comply with the previous proposal by the National Cyber Security Centre,” but this only considers the impact on 5G and not any future measures against fixed line broadband.
Philip Jansen, BT Group CEO, said:
“The security of our networks is an absolute priority for BT. Clearly this decision has logistical and cost implications for communications providers in the UK market – however, we believe the timescales outlined will allow us to make these changes without impacting on the coverage or resilience of our existing networks. It will also allow us to continue to rollout our 5G and full fibre networks without a significant impact on the timescales we’ve previously announced. Whilst we have provided our initial view on the estimated impact today, we will continue to evaluate the details of this decision thoroughly.”
Comments are closed