Home
 » ISP News, Key Developments » 
Sponsored Links

MP Criticises UK Gov Proposal to Spend Rural Broadband Money in Cities

Monday, Oct 7th, 2024 (8:33 am) - Score 1,560
Central-London-UK-Broadband-Picture-2024-123rf

The Shadow Technology Secretary, Andrew Griffith MP, has warned the new UK Government against a “shocking waste of taxpayers’ money” by potentially shifting public funding, which is currently earmarked for the rural-focused Project Gigabit broadband roll-out, and using it to help upgrade parts of major towns and cities (e.g. central London).

Just to recap. The £5bn Project Gigabit scheme aims to help extend 1Gbps (download) capable networks to reach at least 85% of UK premises by 2025 (we’re about to hit this target early), before aiming to achieve “nationwide” coverage (c. 99%) by 2030. Commercial investment has already delivered more than 80% of this, which leaves the government’s scheme to focus on tackling the final 10-20% (mostly rural and some sub-urban areas), where the private sector alone often fails.

NOTE: Project Gigabit is overseen by the government’s executive Building Digital UK agency.

The project primarily consists of several support schemes, including demand-led Gigabit Broadband Vouchers (GBVS) for specific premises (£210m), funding to extend Dark Fibre around the public sector (£110m) and general gap-funded network deployments with suppliers (rest of the funding) – known as the Gigabit Infrastructure Subsidy (GIS) programme.

Advertisement

Most of the project’s funding has already been committed, but around £2bn remains, and the new UK Government are known to be exploring how they could best utilise this in a second phase of the build programme. The first round of contracts and programmes are unlikely to deliver 99%+ gigabit coverage to every location, thus there’s still more work to be done on that side of things.

However, a new report in the Telegraph (via MSN) suggests that BDUK are exploring how at least some of the remaining public investment assigned to the project could be used to help tackle broadband slow-spots and “not-spots” in normally competitive urban areas, such as parts of central London. The article doesn’t specify how this would work, but it’s something the shadow (Conservative) technology secretary isn’t very happy about.

Andrew Griffith MP said:

“If confirmed, this would be a baffling decision by the Labour government that risks leaving people in the hardest to reach rural areas left in the slow lane without any credible path to fast, reliable broadband.

This programme was explicitly designed to build full-fibre to remote areas where the rollout is not economically viable for commercial providers.

To divert the funding to highly competitive areas such as central London would be a shocking waste of taxpayers’ money at a time the Government is snatching pensioners’ winter fuel allowances away.”

A government (DSIT) spokesperson said:

“We have been clear that addressing pockets of poor connectivity in all areas of the country is necessary to reach our goal of nationwide gigabit coverage by 2030 and grow the economy.

Rural areas remain a priority for us, with over a million rural premises now covered by contracts under Project Gigabit – with many more rural properties set to benefit in future. We are committed to exploring all avenues to achieve this ambition. No decisions have been made yet.”

Naturally, there is a bit of a twist to this story, which the Telegraph hasn’t picked up on. This reflects the fact that it was actually the previous government that, in 2023, began the process of exploring how the issue of urban slow and notspots could be tackled (here).

In fact, a trial solution was proposed earlier this year (here), which was due to have extended the gigabit broadband voucher scheme to be used in certain urban, as well as rural, areas (they also did something similar with the original ‘Connection Voucher’ scheme some years ago). But this may have been put on pause by the General Election, pending a decision by the new government.

Advertisement

The reality here is that some urban patches, which are typically dotted about like small islands inside major cities and towns, have long become notorious for being left neglected by commercial operators. The problem can be caused by all sorts of challenges (e.g. high build costs, issues with securing wayleave / access and permits or road closures etc.), while state aid and competition law often make it difficult to use public funding in such areas (i.e. locations where private investment should be able to resolve without intervention).

The easiest solution to the complex legal and competition dilemmas this can raise has typically been to use vouchers, hence the above proposal to extend the existing scheme. But it’s worth remembering that solving such complex areas isn’t always just a matter of money, and vouchers alone may not be enough.

The GBVS currently offers grants worth up to £4,500 to rural homes and businesses to help them get a gigabit-capable broadband service installed, which is available to areas with speeds of “less than 100Mbps” – assuming there are also no future plans for a gigabit deployment (either via private investment or state-aid). Some Local Authorities (LA) have, in the past, also provided top-up funding to boost the voucher values.

Share with Twitter
Share with Linkedin
Share with Facebook
Share with Reddit
Share with Pinterest
Mark-Jackson
By Mark Jackson
Mark is a professional technology writer, IT consultant and computer engineer from Dorset (England), he also founded ISPreview in 1999 and enjoys analysing the latest telecoms and broadband developments. Find me on X (Twitter), Mastodon, Facebook, BlueSky, Threads.net and .
Search ISP News
Search ISP Listings
Search ISP Reviews
Comments
10 Responses

Advertisement

  1. Avatar photo James says:

    Let’s hope there’s some details in the budget at the end of the month, I fear once the country hits 85% gigabyte coverage , they’ll pull the funding?

    1. Avatar photo Will says:

      It has just hit 85%…

  2. Avatar photo Me says:

    I have to say I’m not surprised by this government, I’m surprised they’ll still use the funds for broadband improvements. Not giving it away to foreign nations.
    The UK is a tiny country in comparison to others with copper lines who knows how old in some places. And it looks like the money allocated to fix it will vanish.

    1. Avatar photo Fibre Scrier says:

      Add Me too, on that post.

  3. Avatar photo Peter S says:

    It is my understanding that the GBVS is currently only open in 6 out of the 38 project gigabit lot areas. I am surprised that DSIT haven’t re-opened the scheme in areas where the project gigabit contract was awarded in 2022, where I assume build plans must now be well established.

  4. Avatar photo Obi says:

    For the cities, sometimes it’s not cash that’s the issue, it’s councils/landlords blocking fibre installs, speaking as someone in London still on ADSL.

  5. Avatar photo Rik says:

    Don’t forget certain parts of inner London brought this upon themselves because they didn’t want the “ugly” cabinets blighting their streets.

  6. Avatar photo Mick says:

    I’m horrified to read that money earmarked for rural development might be ‘hijacked’ for urban enhancements.

    I live in a rural area near the Welsh borders. Our telephone network is so poor that a simple voice call is nearly impossible. A couple of yoghurt pots and a length of string would have been better.

    We are also in a mobile blackspot area.

    Thank goodness for starlink (which we purchased a couple of years ago). Yes, it’s expensive, but at least we get a decent service (now better than friends living in the more urban/civilised parts of the UK). We dispensed with BT as soon as starlink was switched on.

    Coincidentally, yesterday, BT have just run GB cable to the telegraph pole in our field. They project that we might be connected up in the the new year. (We’re looking forward to the potential choice of other providers!)

    All this wait and bother was a bit of a joke, especially as leave-ways etc. aren’t an issue. More so when one of Britain’s Earth Stations is just down the road from us (256 acres of telecommunications satellites dishes for civil and military use)

    The government should concentrate on ensuring that the ‘have nots’ get at least a decent connection of any speed before trying to increase the speed of the ‘already haves’

    Mick

    1. Avatar photo SicOf says:

      Too true, national strategy, cohesive management, and a level playinfield, should be raising the minimums not rare hot spots, arguablye it should be a national, i.e. all off it with no left behinds.
      Should be a backbone like national grid, gas, rail and road networks not just a fragnet of ‘individual’ proffit focussed ‘suppliers’.
      After a plan is released shoudl be a clear change process around it, not just whims, or a shoddilly concieved half baked ‘plan’.

    2. Avatar photo John says:

      There are not spots even in London. Turns out openreach cheapening out and not installing ducts makes many areas unviable

Comments are closed

Cheap BIG ISPs for 100Mbps+
Community Fibre UK ISP Logo
200Mbps
Gift: None
Youfibre UK ISP Logo
Youfibre £23.99
150Mbps
Gift: None
Virgin Media UK ISP Logo
Virgin Media £23.99
132Mbps
Gift: None
Plusnet UK ISP Logo
Plusnet £24.99
145Mbps
Gift: £145 Reward Card
NOW UK ISP Logo
NOW £25.00
100Mbps
Gift: None
Large Availability | View All
Cheap Unlimited Mobile SIMs
iD Mobile UK ISP Logo
iD Mobile £16.00
Contract: 24 Months
Data: Unlimited
Talkmobile UK ISP Logo
Talkmobile £16.95
Contract: 1 Month
Data: Unlimited
Smarty UK ISP Logo
Smarty £17.00
Contract: 1 Month
Data: Unlimited
ASDA Mobile UK ISP Logo
ASDA Mobile £19.00
Contract: 24 Months
Data: Unlimited
Three UK ISP Logo
Three £20.00
Contract: 24 Months
Data: Unlimited
Cheapest ISPs for 100Mbps+
toob UK ISP Logo
toob £18.00
150Mbps
Gift: None
Gigaclear UK ISP Logo
Gigaclear £19.00
300Mbps
Gift: None
Community Fibre UK ISP Logo
200Mbps
Gift: None
Beebu UK ISP Logo
Beebu £23.00
100 - 160Mbps
Gift: None
Hey! Broadband UK ISP Logo
150Mbps
Gift: None
Large Availability | View All
Promotion
Sponsored

Copyright © 1999 to Present - ISPreview.co.uk - All Rights Reserved - Terms , Privacy and Cookie Policy , Links , Website Rules , Contact
Mastodon