Posted: 06th Aug, 2010 By: MarkJ

The Managing Director of business ISP
Fluidata, Piers Daniell, has criticised this week's launch of
Annex M ADSL2+ technology by BT (Annex M offers faster broadband upload speeds by trading off some downstream performance) for being both late and delivering a service that fails to work properly with Cisco hardware.
Just to re-cap. A growing number of copper line / BT based UK ISPs currently offer ADSL2+ based broadband services, which provides download speeds of up to 24Mbps and uploads of up to 1.4Mbps. However
Annex M is able to increase upload speeds to around 2.5Mbps, albeit only on good quality lines with an attenuation of less than 45db.
Annex M isn't new and some unbundled ( LLU ) ISPs, such as Be Broadband ( O2 ), have been offering it for years. Crucially you can already get it at a consumer pricing level from BE at just £21.97 per month alongside their most flexible
BE PRO package. By comparison BT based ISPs will be more expensive.
Piers Daniell commented:"How can BT talk about this being new technology when we have been offering it for over four years? We interconnect directly into the BE network (wholly owned by Telefonica O2 group) and have been delivering up to 2.5 Mb/s upstream to customers for all of this time, even using Cisco hardware."
However Daniell's main gripe is not with how late BT are to the party but the fact that "
most businesses" could have difficulty adapting to BT's implementation of Annex M because it doesn't work well with Cisco technology.
Piers Daniell continued:
"There is an old saying in the industry that goes ‘you don’t get fired for buying Cisco’. Granted it is pretty expensive but in all the years of doing it I can count the failures customer have had on one hand rather than the calculator I would need to tot up other ‘cheaper’ manufacturer’s hardware.
So you would think that if you were building a national network and launched a new variant (ie Annex-M) you would want your technology to work with Cisco hardware so you could conquer the business market? Well believe it or not, BT have followed the route of Tiscali and ended up with a network that we can’t make work with Cisco hardware! We are struggling to make it work at all to be honest."
It's difficult to determine whether this is a truly widespread problem, although Daniell appears adamant that "
most businesses [do] like to buy [Cisco]". Unfortunately there are no clear figures for accurately assessing Cisco's share of the UK network/internet devices market. It would be interesting to know whether other providers have experienced similar gripes with BT's Annex M.