Posted: 22nd Apr, 2010 By: MarkJ
Mobile operator T-Mobile has come top in a test of roaming UK Mobile Broadband performance and also managed to achieve an average download speed of 1.9Mbps. The
Broadband Genie 2010 Road Trip saw USB Modems (Dongles) from six mobile providers ( O2 , Orange , Three (3) , T-Mobile , Virgin Media and Vodafone UK) taken out of their safety zone and simultaneously tested throughout a two-day 350 mile rail trip.
Download average speed: T-Mobile saw a massive fluctuation in results, but its massive lead in top speeds saw its average come out on top at around 1.9Mb. Virgin Media had much more consistent results, averaging 1.5Mb, while it was a similar story with Vodafone (1.2Mb). The rest averaged below 1Mb, with O2 (0.8Mb) getting a better average, but suffering the most failures. 3 just pipped Orange, but both were around the 0.5Mb mark. Everyone improved a little on last year, with only T-Mobile's significant top-end improvement making a big move overall.
Upload average speed: Virgin Media came out on top by a significant distance, managing an impressive average of more than 1Mb. Both T-Mobile and 3 averaged more than 0.6Mb, big improvements on last year, while being a little erratic. Vodafone, O2 and Orange were at least consistent around the 0.3Mb mark - small progress for Orange, a stand still for O2 and a fall for Vodafone.
Dongle on the Move 2010 winner: T-Mobile Runner up: Virgin Media UK
Sub-categories
Road Trip Downloader 2010 winner: T-Mobile Runner up: Virgin Media UK
Road Trip Uploader 2010 winner: T-Mobile Runner up: Three (3) UK
Road Trip's Most Stable 2010 winner: Vodafone Runner up: Orange UK
Road Trip Coverage 2010 joint winners: T-Mobile & Virgin Media UK
Dongle Software 2010 winner: Vodafone Runner up: T-Mobile UK
It should be noted that Virgin Media receive their network service from T-Mobile , so it's perhaps no surprise to see both coming close in the results. However there were some big differences between the two, which perhaps highlights the difficulty of accurately benchmarking a Mobile Broadband service.