Extremely significant and unexpected drops in service speed that continue for longer than a few days can be a serious matter (e.g. real-world daytime rates of 6Mbps drop to 1Mbps). It’s important to make sure that natural peak usage trends or traffic management policies (heavy users be warned – P2P and online video services are often targeted with specific restrictions) are not to blame. Don’t be afraid to change ISP if it underperforms.
Broadband is a variable “
best efforts” service but you should not accept a dramatically slower speed than your line is PREDICTED to cope with, especially if the problem occurs throughout the day and no traffic or fair usage policies are being deliberately applied (ask your ISP). Some BT based ISPs will consider anything below 400Kbps to be a line fault requiring investigation, though internal policies do vary.
Under Ofcom’s voluntary Code of Practice (CoP) on speeds, which 95% of UK ISPs have already agreed to (
CoP ISP LIST), broadband providers must:
• Provide consumers at the point of sale with an accurate estimate of the maximum speed that their line can support.
• Explain clearly and simply how technical factors may slow down speeds, while also offering help and advice to consumers to improve the situation at home.
• Offer an alternative package (if there is one) without any penalties, if the actual speed is a lot lower than the original estimate.
• Explain fair usage policies (FUP) clearly and alert consumers when they have been breached.
UPDATE August 2010
Ofcom has moved to toughen its Voluntary Code of Practice on Broadband Speeds ("the Code") by issuing a new Version 2.0 edition of the code (here) that is even stricter. However, at the time of writting, fewer ISPs had agreed to the v2 code than for v1 (v2 ISP Members). ISPs have been given 6-12 months to adapt to the new code. The key additions follow:
• Greater consistency and accuracy of information on speeds achievable by consumers: instead of getting a maximum line speed estimate in the form of a single point estimate, consumers will be given a range which is more likely to be accurate than the single point estimate.
• Giving customers the option to be released from their contracts: consumers will have a new right to be able to leave their contracts without penalty if they receive an maximum line speed which is significantly below the bottom of the estimated range and ISPs are not able to resolve the problem (e.g. by sending an iPlate).
• Ensuring consumers are given their estimated maximum line speed early in the sales process, well before being asked for a firm commitment to sign-up.
• Ensuring consumers are given clear written information that actual speeds may be below both advertised headline speeds and maximum line speeds, as well as information about the other factors affecting actual speeds, including the ISP's fair usage and traffic management policies.
Customers experiencing problems like this with their ISP should run a series of
Broadband Speed Tests at different times of the day over several days to see if they can spot any trends. It’s also worth trying to see if performance varies between different services or websites, as this may signal a problem with the remote site (or traffic management) rather than your ISP. When reporting a problem with speed to your ISP it is a good idea to have screenshots of your speedtest results (make a note of the date and time they were conducted).
Problems with speed can also occur due to physical line problems, environmental electrical interference (Christmas tree lights, AC adaptors, microwave ovens etc.) or an issue with your broadband router/modem ; it may not be the fault of your ISP. The ‘
Broadband ADSL Connection Tips’ article we wrote should be helpful in diagnosing most problems.
More advanced users should also consider running a traceroute, which tests the flow of traffic between your connection and another server. Problems can be identified by any servers in the chain that either time-out (fail to work), run very slowly (500ms/miliseconds+ is usually quite bad) and or experience noticable packet loss.
It’s very important to be aware that most of these rules and situations relate to traditional land based telephone providers. Do not apply the same principals to Mobile Broadband (T-Mobile, Vodafone etc.) services, where dramatic fluctuations in speed are to be expected.
I have been using an ISP called Metronet for several years without any major problems. Metronet had been purchases by PlusNet but this did not seem to affect my service.
Just before Christmas I received an email notifying me that they were "upgrading" my service from "up to 8MB" to "up to 20MB" which you would think was a good thing.
Unfortunately this upgrade did not work well - my connection had been stable at approx 3MB DSL downstream for the past couple of years (I am in a rural area and not close to the exchange).
I'm sure that no-one is really interested in the gory details of what went wrong (initially consistently slow speeds and then total failure of connection - to reconnect everything had to be switched off for at least 65 minutes at which point it would work for about an hour then fail again).
The real problem I had was the lack of interest in solving the problem. After a month with several phone calls (don't you just love waiting in a queue listening to "Is this the way to Amarillo") and at least 20 web-mails (sent using a connection over a mobile connection) the problem still exists.
Their entire "fault handling" proceedure seemed designed to "make me go away" rather than to help resolve faults. I accept that problems are often in home wiring, with the microfilter, with the router etc however when these have all been checked (several times) continually answering emails with, and I quote:-
"If you can confirm that your are connected to the test socket (located behind the master socket faceplate) and have changed the microfilter, then we can raise a fault for you.
Please note; if an Engineer visits your premises and the fault is found to be caused by your equipment, internal wiring or as a result of damage to BT equipment a charge of £60 will apply"
just makes me really, really annoyed.
Anyway eventually I've just given up and cancelled my direct debit - just was annoyed enough to write this in the (probably futile) hope that someone will read it and decide to use a different ISP rather than PlusNet.
My problem was simple, I have a faulty modem which required replacing. I let Virgin Media know two weeks ago and they agreed to send out an engineer three days later. This is quite a long time to wait without Internet, but I had no choice. I then received a call two days later saying there was a fault in the local area and that my engineer was cancelled.
I called them again to rebook, and they told me that local area faults automatically cancel your engineer, even though my faultly modem had nothing to do with this issue.
Two weeks later, I've now had to rebook my engineer 4 times, and each of those four engineers have been cancelled. I'm now currently waiting for my fifth to be sent out, but I suspect this will likely be cancelled also.
This is a ridiculous policy of theirs, and as there was no hope for me to ever get an engineer I have now switched. This is EXTREMELY poor customer service from Virgin Media. They even went as far as promising me my next engineer would not be cancelled, only for it to happen days later. When asked about why it was cancelled (despite a note being left for this to specifically NOT happen) they simply said.. "I don't know who said that but that's wrong, we don't have a record of that".
This is simply unacceptable. I sincerely hope noone else goes through what I have. I have called them on fifteen seperate occassions over the last week, waiting 15 minutes each time while I was on hold, only to rebook engineers that get cancelled days later.
Most people on Virgin Media who have not had any issues (which I hear are very few) are likely to be unaware of just how poor their customer service is, unless they're own modem fails and they go through what I have.
Their Indian call centres are also just as shambolic as their UK ones (99% of the time, you will be put through to an Indian call centre). The UK team manager Victoria Holland was just as unhelpful as the other 'managers'. Appalling service.
Virgin Media are a poor ISP, I would NEVER recommend them to anyone else.